There is a misconception that going to counseling is going to get advice. In actuality, counselors are more of an educated sounding board, blank page, or way to discover what the client thinks. Counselor are not supposed to give advice. But now with the advent of "speed shrinking" advice is inevitable. You pose your question and get advice, almost fortune cookie type advice. The advice is necessarily shallow because the "relationship" is shallow.
Example of fortune cookie advice:
One middle-aged man told another therapist, Diana Kirschner, that he was worried about becoming unemployed. “I worry about losing my job, because I’m too young to get fired and too old to get hired,” said the man...[The counselor] asked the man if he had other interests. When he said he wanted to write a book, she responded: “Pursue this new venture. When you are in a situation like this, you must reinvent yourself.”
Does this help? Is this truly the best advice? Or just an easy answer to have something in 3 minutes.
Example of shallow advice:
...a 24-year-old product development manager at Ralph Lauren in New York, approached Ms. Kirschner to ask about the merits of online dating.
“Is it wrong?” she asked. “Is it a normal way to meet people?”
“It is very normal,” Ms. Kirschner answered. “As of 2007, the majority of people over 45 were meeting their lifelong loves online, and not through the traditional network of family, friends and business associates, and I believe this is now true for younger people.”
Why is she wondering? What is behind the question? And just because it is "normal" does not mean it is okay for her.
Even though we are an instant gratification society, there are just some things that take time. Counseling is one of them.
The Sport Mind: lessons from sports
I see the sporting world as a microcosm of our society, and that makes it an ideal place to learn how to function best in our society. If you read my blog, you will read personal anecdotes, whimsical thoughts, philosophical ponderings, observations, research, articles, ideas, and quotes - but all will, however loosely, deal with the mental side of sports and how lessons learned there can be used in life. (Note, as my header might suggest, that I am a swimmer, and many posts, though maybe applicable to all sports, will pertain to swimming.)
8.31.2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment